Brahmi Inscriptions from Kondane Caves

The aim of the paper is to analyze the Brahmi inscriptions engraved at Kondane caves. All the previous research works have recorded and studied only one donation that was made by Balaka, a disciple of Kanha. Apart from this inscription, three more inscriptions have been noted. In our quest to search them we could locate only one in situ that has been photo documented and analyzed.


Introduction
From the early Buddhist narratives, we learn that Buddhism has made inroads in western India during the lifetime of the Buddha.
Three narratives from the theragatha refer to Punna, Isidinna and Vaddha from western India. Punna was the son of a wealthy merchant Bhava from Shurparaka who travelled to Shravasti where he met the Buddha. After being initiated as a monk he returned to Sronanaparanta where he successfully converted large number of men and women. (Joel Tatelman: Unpublished Thesis, 1988) Isidinna, a thera was a son of a sethi from Sronaaparanta. Having heard the Buddha preach, he became a Sotāpanna. Vaddha belonged to a Gahapatikula or householder's family from Broach. He along with his mother joined the sangha.
Mention also be made of Bavari, was a royal priest of the King of Kosala. He later became an anchorite and set up an ashrama in the Ashmaka country identified in the present Godavari Basin. His sixteen disciples met the Buddha and sought answers to various philosophical questions. Pingiliya, his nephew returned and recounted all the acquired knowledge to Bavari. (Gokhale 1972: 231) However, it was during the reign of Emperor Ashoka in 3 rd BCE that Buddhism emerged as a distinct religion with great potentialities for expansion. A decision was taken in the third Buddhist Council presided over by Mogaliputta Tissa. Per which monks were sent far and wide to spread the word of Dhamma. A Yavana called Yona Dharmarakshita was then sent to Aparanta where he is said to have successfully converted many people including women and nobles to Buddhism. (Mahavamsha: Ch XII) • Along with these literary evidences, the fragments of Rock Edicts 8 (Indraji 1882: 10-16) & 9 (Sircar 1957: 5-6) of Emperor Ashoka have been discovered at Sopara. These literary and epigraphic evidences prove that Buddhism had made its definite inroads in western India by 3 rd BCE.

Rise of Rock Cut Caves in Western Deccan
Early Buddhist missionaries must have gravitated to the niches in Sahyadri mountains to suit the needs of their ideas of asceticism and the monastic life. By 1 st century BCE, Hippalus, a Greek navigator discovered the monsoon winds, that concurred with the rise of Satavahana power in Deccan. A flourishing trade utilizing the sea routes with the western world ensued thereafter. Emergence of the monasteries on the ancient trade routes was not a mere coincidence. Many traders financially supported these establishments which is evident by the donative inscriptions at these rock hewn caves. In fact, the rock cut monasteries became a rich repository of such donations recording the donations of the royals, feudals, monks, nuns and lay devotees.

Locating the inscriptions at Kondane
Unlike other contemporary rock hewn caves at Bhaje, Karle and Bedse, no inscriptions are visible inside the chaitya griha. The pillars and the stupa are in dilapidated condition that probably deprived us of the valuable information.
As Dikshit, M G has noted fourth inscription in his unpublished thesis. He reads it as 'Hamma of (i.e. donated by) Prakara.' Thereby identifying the Kondane establishment of a Hammiya type. (Dutta 2015: 96) However this inscription too could not be located by us in situ.

First Inscription
As seen in the photograph (Figure 2)     A comparison with these two inscriptions will allow us to arrive at a plausible date of the first inscription. All the letters in this inscription are well in conformity with its Sopara counterpart except the letter 'va' which is seen with a rounded shape with small vertical line on top. Similar type of rounded 'va' is seen in the Nashik inscription of King Kanha.

Paleography of the inscription
However, in this inscription it has taken triangular shape suggesting its early Satavahana period origin in conformity with the dating of the architecture.

Second Inscription
As seen in the photograph (Figure 4) the second inscription is engraved on the lowermost cornice of the overhanging cave. This Prakrit Brahmi inscription is read in the flyer uploaded at the website of the Archaeological Survey of India (Western Circle) (http://asimumbaicircle.com) as,

Sidham barakasa dhammayakhasa Kanchikaputasa po(thira?)
The inscription is neither translated in the flyer nor by S. Nagaraju who mentions it as unpublished. Nagaraju has retained same reading of this inscription. (Nagaraju 1981: 339) Nagaraju also suggests the reading of the last word as 'pavado'.
A discrepancy is observed in the reading after evaluating the inscription at Kondane. We read the inscription as  Budharakhitasa matu deyadhamma patho ano (Mirashi 1981: 55-57) 'There is another pious gift of the mother of Buddharakshita behind (this cave)'. V. V. Mirashi suggests that '...... if 'patho' is amended into 'pathe' (prushthe), the intended meaning may be 'there is another (mandapa) behind (this).' (Mirashi 1981: 55-57) As seen in the photograph (Figure 6), here at Kondane too is a vihara behind the façade where the present inscription is engraved. If the above explanation is accepted, then the vihara was possibly donated by Ha(dha)mayaksha.

Paleography of the Inscription
As seen in the earlier inscription, this inscription too shows all the characteristics of the early Satavahana characters. Its posterity to the Ashoka's edicts of the 3 rd BCE is marked by the inverted 'dha' shown as D.
However, the letter 'ma' still shows the rounded features of the Ashokan type.
The letter 'ma' has taken a clear triangular shape in the Nashik inscription of the reign of King Kanha (Krishna). Letter 'ma' has retained its rounded shape in the Naneghat Inscription of Satavahana queen Naganika that immediately succeeds the Nashik inscription of King Krishna. It must be noted that the letter 'dha' is of inverted type ( D) in Naneghat inscription. Thus, this inscription finds more similarities with the Naneghat inscription.

OPEN ACCESS
Ancient Asia is a peer-reviewed open access journal published by Ubiquity Press.

Third Inscription
As per the records of Archaeological Survey of India, the third inscription is located on the lowermost cornice of the overhanging projection of the façade decorated with chaitya arches. (http://asimumbaicircle.com) and reads as follows:

Kanchikaputasa deyadhama
Nagaraju, S also has retained the same reading and marked this inscription as unpublished. (Nagaraju 1981: 339) It can be translated as the donation by the son of Kanchika. This brief inscription suggests that Ha(dha) mayaksha made another donation at Kondane, though his name is not mentioned in the inscription.
In spite of our vigorous search we could not find this inscription. In the absence of any physical record it is difficult to ascertain the nature of this donation or the actual reading.